First, a ferocious fire. Now a slow, grim search for the dead in Lahaina
DNA specialists who have been working with Ukrainian investigators to document suspected Russian war crimes. Veterans of the post-Sept. 11 search at ground zero. Anthropologists who were enlisted to examine human remains after the California wildfire that until last week was America’s deadliest in more than a century.
They are among the experts who have been arriving in Maui this week to join the painstaking process of recovering and identifying at least 101 people who perished last week in the historic Hawaii town of Lahaina.
“Over the course of the next 10 days, this number could double,” Gov. Josh Green of Hawaii said Monday in an interview on CNN. “I don’t want to really guess at a number because our people are working so hard right now.”
Many of the people being called on to help played similar roles in the aftermath of the Camp fire, the 2018 disaster in Northern California that killed 85 people and reduced to ash the town of Paradise, in the foothills of the Sierra Nevada.
Kim Gin, the former Sacramento County coroner who led the effort to identify the remains of victims of the Camp fire, flew into Maui on Monday. Forensic anthropologists from California State University, Chico, who assisted at the Camp fire were scrambling this week to arrange travel to Hawaii.
And scientists with ANDE, a company based in Colorado that uses rapid DNA technology — which processes results in less than two hours with a device the size of a laser printer — have been on the ground in Hawaii for days, and more technicians were on their way.
Don't miss out on what's happening!
Stay in touch with top news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. It's FREE!
Also in Lahaina are rescuers who worked in the rubble of the World Trade Center after Sept. 11, Maui’s police chief, John Pelletier, said. Twenty cadaver dogs are working with search teams, along with a specialized mortuary unit from the federal government that arrived with a 22-ton mobile morgue that includes examination tables, lab equipment and X-ray machines.
With families facing an agonizing wait for word on missing loved ones, the final death toll from the Aug. 8 fire is likely to continue climbing, and the full scope of human loss may not be known for weeks, or perhaps months.
“I understand people want numbers,” Pelletier said at a news conference Monday. “It’s not a numbers game.”
As of this evening in Hawaii, authorities had yet to publicly identify any of the 101 people who have been confirmed dead, and the search for more victims was continuing.
Authorities said today that they had searched 32% of the burn zone in Lahaina, which runs from the hillsides to the Pacific Ocean, and the area was closed to the public while teams searched for remains, even as residents grew increasingly frustrated in not being able to return to Lahaina to check on their properties.
Pelletier said one person had been arrested on a trespassing charge, and he had a message for others who might try to enter the area illegally. “It’s not just ash on your clothing when you take it off,” he said. “It’s our loved ones.”
The police have asked family members of the missing to submit DNA swabs at a community center in Maui for comparisons to recovered remains. Pelletier asked relatives who are out of state to provide DNA to their local law enforcement agencies.
Maui County released the identities of the first two victims this evening, and said the death toll is now 106
ANDE, whose technology was funded in part by the Department of Homeland Security, is often used by law enforcement agencies to investigate crimes and crack cold cases. For the past year, the company has been involved in the war in Ukraine, training the local police to examine victims of suspected war crimes and collect evidence that could be used at trials at the International Criminal Court at The Hague. Its technology was also used when 34 people died in a fire on a dive boat off Santa Barbara, California, in 2019, and to process remains from the helicopter crash that killed Kobe Bryant a few months later.
“The challenge, of course, is the remains you process and the family samples don’t always coincide,” said Stephen Meer, the chief information officer of ANDE, which is processing samples of remains as they are collected by search teams in Lahaina. “If you are missing someone, get your family reference sample in.”
Meer said he was confident that most of the victims would eventually be identified by DNA — during the Camp fire, close to 90% of those who perished were identified with ANDE’s tests — but he added, “I can’t imagine it would be for all.”
As recovery teams search for human remains, others have been looking for lost and dead pets. “People are desperately searching for pets,” said Lisa Labrecque, the CEI of the Maui Humane Society.
Labrecque estimated that 3,000 animals had been lost, and she said that her organization had received 367 reports of missing pets. She said her teams had been rescuing injured or displaced animals each day. They have recovered 57 live animals, 12 of which are hospitalized. They have been able to reunite eight animals with their owners. To make space, the Humane Society was sending animals that had been living in its shelters before the fire to the mainland. More than 150 cats and kittens have been flown out, and 100 dogs were waiting to travel.
As search teams with cadaver dogs continue their slow process of sorting through the rubble of Lahaina, anthropologists — who often play a pivotal role in processing mass casualty scenes — were being dispatched to help in identifying human remains that might be just shards of bone. “We know what burned human remains look like and can differentiate them from an animal or something someone might have had in a kitchen,” said Marin Pilloud, a professor of anthropology at the University of Nevada, Reno.
Pilloud was involved in recovering remains after the Camp fire. The process was methodical: Working from a list of the missing and any information about where those people might have been at the time of the fire, she joined teams that would conduct searches at specific addresses.
“One step was to see if they were in fact trapped in their house,” she said. “So we would sift through all the debris of the house and try to identify if there were remains there.”
She said that in the moonscape left by a fire as destructive as the one that wiped out Lahaina, many items collected in an ashcan could appear to be human remains.
“Like drywall of the house can sometimes curl up in a way that looks like bone,” she said. “Insulation can sometimes melt in ways that look like bone.”
She added, “We are trained in these sort of archaeological recovery efforts, so we can systematically go through and try to identify if there are remains there.”
—
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
© 2023 The New York Times Company