Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Wednesday, December 11, 2024 76° Today's Paper


Top News

Activists protest ‘Watters World’ Chinatown story in front of Fox News

1/2
Swipe or click to see more
2/2
Swipe or click to see more

ASSOCIATED PRESS

In this Oct. 28, 2013 file photo,”The O’Reilly Factor” anchor Bill O’Reilly attends the National Geographic Channel’s “Killing Kennedy” world premiere screening reception at The Newseum, in Washington.

Elected officials and activists staged a protest outside the Manhattan headquarters of Fox News on Thursday over a segment in which a correspondent conducted a series of mocking interviews of Asian-Americans in New York City’s Chinatown that critics said trafficked in stereotypes and veered into racism.

The correspondent, Jesse Watters, who has been accused of stalking and harassment for his ambush-style interviews on the street, expressed “regret” late Wednesday after provoking a storm of criticism for the segment that was broadcast Monday.

Mayor Bill de Blasio called the segment “vile.” And Councilman Peter Koo said in a statement: “Passing off this blatantly racist television segment as ‘gentle fun’ not only validates racist stereotypes, it encourages them. The entire segment smacks of willful ignorance by buying into the perpetual foreigner syndrome.

“How is it, that in New York City in 2016, this is still OK? Short answer: It’s not, and it is unfortunate that Fox News needs to be reminded of that.”

Fox broadcast the interviews as part of “Watters’ World,” a recurring segment on “The O’Reilly Factor,” the network’s top-rated show. The host, Bill O’Reilly, introduced the piece by saying it had been inspired by how frequently China was mentioned during the first presidential debate between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump.

But the nearly five-minute video was interspersed with references to martial arts and scenes of Watters getting a foot massage, playing with nunchucks and asking loaded questions that some residents appeared not to understand or couldn’t answer. Clips from well-known movies were sprinkled throughout the segment, including “The Karate Kid” and “Chinatown.”

Watters begins the piece with an instrumental version of the Carl Douglas song “Kung Fu Fighting” playing softly in the background. He asks two young women, “Am I supposed to bow to say hello?” He asks a street vendor if his wares were stolen: “I like these watches — are they hot?”

When he asks some passers-by their opinion of Clinton and Trump, the two men answer in accented English, and their answers are displayed in subtitles at the bottom of the screen.

“Trump has been beating up on China; how does that make you feel?” he asks an older woman. He peppers others with questions like “Is it the year of the dragon … rabbit?” “Is everything made in China now?” “Do they call Chinese food in China just food?”

And at one point, when another young woman says she really doesn’t want to vote for Trump so her choice was Clinton, he opines, “So China can keep ripping us off.”

The segment provoked an uproar among social media users, and Asian-American groups denounced it. The Asian-American Journalists Association said it was “outraged and shocked” and demanded an apology from the network.

“We should be far beyond tired, racist stereotypes and targeting an ethnic group for humiliation and objectification on the basis of their race,” the group said in a statement. “Sadly, Fox News proves it has a long way to go in reporting on communities of color in a respectful and fair manner.”

The influential blog Angry Asian Man, founded by Phil Yu, a Korean-American, described the segment in a post as “a new low, even for Fox News.”

“Jesse Watters went for a holy-crap-that’s-so-racist-man-on-the-street approach,” the post said.

State Sen. Daniel L. Squadron, whose district includes Chinatown, condemned the segment for “stereotyping, mockery and a thinly veiled disdain for immigrants.”

In addition to Koo, Comptroller Scott M. Stringer, U.S. Reps. Grace Meng and Nydia Velasquez, and state Assemblymen Ron Kim and Walter T. Mosley attended the rally Thursday, according to a statement from the New York state Black, Puerto Rican, Hispanic and Asian Legislative Caucus.

Watters, who responded to his critics Wednesday on Twitter, said he considered himself “a political humorist” and regretted that he had upset people. He said his interviews were meant to be taken as a lighthearted joke.

Watters and O’Reilly, however, appeared to anticipate that the interviews would cause a stir when the segment was broadcast Monday.

“I know we’re going to get letters,” O’Reilly said. “It’s inevitable.” The Fox host added that he was surprised, considering how “insulated” he believed the residents of Chinatown were, that many seemed to be aware of what was going on politically.

Watters said one man who had responded negatively to him was “one of many” who “hated” him. “They’re such a polite people — they won’t walk away or tell me to get out of here,” he said, laughing.

“They’re patient, they’re patient,” O’Reilly replied.

Renee Tajima-Peña, a professor of Asian-American studies at the University of California, Los Angeles, said the segment captured a long-standing and distinct feature of anti-Asian sentiment in the United States.

“They mock the Chinese and Chinese-Americans, yet the backhanded compliments — he said these people were so polite,” Tajima-Peña said. “That kind of duality of the perception of Asians has been there since time immemorial and the beginning of the republic.”

“We are either perpetual foreigners or we are the favored model minority,” she added. “We are a threat or we are docile.”

Watters has been at the center of controversy before. He became known for street interviews that sometimes seemed to serve little purpose save for bothering critics of Fox News or O’Reilly. In 2009, Amanda Terkel, then an editor at the liberal website Think Progress, wrote that she had been “accosted” by Watters while on vacation in a town two hours from where she lived.

She said she had been “followed, harassed and ambushed,” and referred to him as “O’Reilly’s top hit man.”

That incident reared its head years later, when Watters found himself in a brawl at the U.S. Institute of Peace during an after-party for the annual White House Correspondents Dinner.

The fight began when Ryan Grim, a reporter at The Huffington Post, where Terkel is currently employed, tried to film Watters with an iPhone. Fisticuffs soon followed.

“Ambush guy can’t take getting ambushed,” Grim told The Washington Post. “Maybe he should think about his life choices.”

© 2016 The New York Times Company

19 responses to “Activists protest ‘Watters World’ Chinatown story in front of Fox News”

  1. calentura says:

    It may have been funny the first time or two, the man-on-the-street interview that inevitably displays the ignorance of many people. Now, it’s just old, hackneyed, demeaning, and ignorant in its own right. And not funny any more.

  2. ezridah says:

    he should do that kind of interview during a Black Lives Matter demonstration and ask black stereotype questions…after all it’s all jokes..

  3. kimo says:

    OK, I just watched it on YouTube — http://tinyurl.com/h8sd8d4. I didn’t think it was demeaning in any way. And those interviewed seemed to enjoy it. Watters himself was respectful and entertaining. It was a rare glimpse into a world that we don’t see very often on TV. It was also “on topic” (in terms of the show) and showed a human side of Chinese in the USA when the country of China is in the news.

  4. username_required says:

    The interviews sound like they were given by Howard Stern’s sidekick, Stuttering Bob.

  5. biggerdog says:

    Star Advertiser is working all the mileage out of this they can.
    What’s the big deal? It’s all a bunch of faux outrage. Have you ever seen Frank Delima in action? Politically correct no way, everyone gets the fork from Frank. He should be silent going forward then? Sheesh. Everyone has a thin skin nowadays.

    • wn says:

      I’m glad you mentioned Frank…so really now..what’s the problem? I’m an Asian American and I saw it as humor versus a malicious attack on our proud ethnic group. Were there any of the plastic bag activists out in front of the Fox headquarters?

      • dontbelieveinmyths says:

        It’s because liberals can’t stand on their own two feet. Any words that can be contorted as being offensive is an opportunity to play the victim. In the liberal world, the victim is the proverbial squeaky wheel. They will get the grease.

  6. CEI says:

    I’ll bet little Barry Hussein wishes he could go back to his community organizer days so he can stir the racial animosity pot. Oh wait a minute he’s never quit stirring the pot. Well it just shows to go you, you can take the boy out of the community organizer but you can’t take the community organizer out of the boy.

    • kimo says:

      CEI, if by “boy” you’re referring to our President Obama, then you’re way out of line. I’ve read many of your other posts, and I respect your opinions even though I don’t always agree with them. I’m assuming that this use of “boy” in the context of the president is unintentional.

  7. wn says:

    “Yellow Journalism”…opps…did I offend anyone?

  8. st1d says:

    the news of the fbi’s agreement to destroy evidence to secure a non-prosecution for the female felon coupled with the discovery of boxes of secret emails in the female felon’s storage has the congenital liar’s brown shirts escalating their attacks on fox using the thinnest claims of racism to deflect attention from her trust issues and failing health.

  9. lespark says:

    Hillary Clinton called President Obama “incompetent and feckless” and charged that he had “no hand on the tiller half the time” during a boozy reunion with college pals, a new book claims.

    The scathing attacks came as the wine was flowing at a May 2013 dinner at Le Jardin Du Roi, a cozy French bistro near the Clinton family home in Westchester, according to “Blood Feud,” by best-selling author Edward Klein.

    “Look, the average Democrat is jus plain $tupid. They’re easy to manipulate. That’s the east part.”
    Hillary Clinton as told to Dick Morris in “Rewriting History” 2005.

  10. HRS134 says:

    Cry babies.

  11. timopd says:

    What’s an Activisit?

    • CEI says:

      An activist is defined as: A humorless, perpetually angry rabble rouser with too much time on his hands. They generally do not work and parasite off hard working taxpayers enabling them to show up at all the fashionable social justice warrior events where they hyper-ventilate and shout mindless slogans. Then there’s the endangered conservative activist sometimes known as a Tea Partier. But they work for a living and do not have as much time to demonstrate. Barry Hussein’s IRS has almost succeeded in driving them to extinction.

  12. Ronin006 says:

    Watters has been conducting these interviews for several years. Most of the people he has interviewed have been Caucasians who showed how ignorant they were about major national and world affairs. Where was the outrage from the so-called political leaders who are making a big fuss about the Chinatown interviews? My wife is a native-born Asian. Neither she or I were offended by what Watters did. The country is going crazy with political correctness. Everyone needs to lighten up and have a laugh once in a while.

  13. deepdiver311 says:

    whats the big deal? jesse wattters is a funny guy and not a racist.
    i laugh with him
    he my #1 tv guy

Leave a Reply