Progress slows on uninsured as health law blame game goes on
WASHINGTON » Progress in reducing the number of people without health insurance in the U.S. appears to be losing momentum this year even as rising premiums and dwindling choice are reviving the political blame game over President Barack Obama’s health care law.
The future of the Affordable Care Act hinges on the outcome of the presidential election, and it’s shaping up as a moment of truth for Republicans.
If Donald Trump wins and follows through on repealing “Obamacare,” Republicans will be judged on how many people are covered — or lose coverage — by the still-evolving GOP replacement plan. If Democrat Hillary Clinton wins, the single-minded Republican focus on repeal will look even more futile.
Underscoring the stakes, a national survey finds that progress reducing the number of uninsured has slowed dramatically. The Gallup-Healthways Well-Being Index shows that the uninsured rate among adults dropped by only about 1 percentage point from 2015 through this July. That’s much less than measured in each of the past two years, since the law’s big coverage expansion started in 2014.
The survey, which polls 500 people nearly every day, is seen as a bellwether. Overall, Gallup-Healthways found that the uninsured rate among adults dropped from 17.3 percent in 2013 just before the law’s coverage expansion, to 10.8 percent currently. That translates to roughly 16.1 million adults gaining coverage over the entire period.
“It’s like box office results for a movie,” said survey director Dan Witters. “It has a big opening weekend and then it slows down over time.”
Don't miss out on what's happening!
Stay in touch with top news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. It's FREE!
Only a change in the politics of health care can shift those numbers. That could happen, for example, if Clinton wins and Republican governors and legislators in big states such as Texas and Florida accept the law’s Medicaid expansion. But in the thick of an election campaign, both sides have an interest in maintaining their fixed positions.
The blame game has a familiar narrative.
Democrats say the law would be working much better if not for GOP obstinacy. Dug-in Republicans fostered an illusion among their fervent supporters that “Obamacare” could be dispatched easily. They kept pushing for repeal even though they knew Obama would never sign such legislation. With repeal as their official dogma, Republicans left no political space for pragmatic adjustments, the kind that divided government has produced before.
Kathleen Sebelius, Obama’s first health secretary, said Republicans have put ideology before people. She cited the failure of most GOP-led states to expand Medicaid, even with the federal government footing nearly all the cost.
“It is morally offensive when we have government blocking people from life-saving health care because of politics,” Sebelius said.
Republicans say the White House and congressional Democrats designed an unworkable program and rammed it through Congress on a party-line vote using a special procedure meant for deficit-related legislation. If premiums are now jumping and major insurers are bailing out, Democrats have only their heavy-handed approach to blame, they say.
“It continues to offer a viable contrast between the two parties,” said GOP pollster Bill McInturff, who is working to re-elect Arizona Sen. John McCain. That state has become a parable for “Obamacare” critics, with the first county in the nation in which no insurer has stepped forward to offer health law coverage for next year.
Obama’s law has reduced the nation’s uninsured rate to a historic low through a combination of subsidized private insurance and expanded Medicaid for low-income people. But it’s been no panacea for the twin problems of high health care costs and barriers to access.
Six years after the law passed, about 29 million people are still uninsured, even if coverage is now a legal obligation for those who can afford it. Insurance plans provided through the health law’s markets can be stingy, prompting some liberals to call the law the “Unaffordable Care Act.”
A poll this year by the nonpartisan Kaiser Family Foundation found that consumers getting coverage through the health law’s markets were split about whether they were getting their money’s worth, a change from previous years when a majority said they were getting a good deal.
That was before the bad news for 2017. Complaining of losses from sicker-than-expected customers, insurers are raising premiums by double-digit percentages in many communities. Some major insurance companies are exiting the markets or scaling back their roles, leaving many areas with less competition.
Republican health economist Gail Wilensky says both parties bear responsibility for the problems. If Clinton manages to stave off Trump, Republicans will have no choice but to accept the health overhaul, she said.
“I know of no historical precedent to suggest a rollback of a major benefit program affecting as many millions of people,” Wilensky said.
Just having a different president — even if it’s Clinton — could shift the political dynamics, said Republican Mike Leavitt, health secretary for President George W. Bush. “A new president can change the game by being willing to negotiate on things the Obama administration was unwilling to.”
5 responses to “Progress slows on uninsured as health law blame game goes on”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
This was a terrible idea, put upon Americans by the Democrat party. There were “NO” Republicans that signed-on to this legislation. Let’s remember that Obama had both the Senate and the House. They even boasted about not needing any Republicans. Let’s not forget Pelosi’s incredibly condescending words:
“we’ll have to pass the bill, before we tell you what’s inside the bill.” Fact is, neither she, nor any other Democrats read any of it. They did as they were told, and completely destroyed, not just the health insurance industry in America, they destroyed health-care. Hopefully, America’s next President will move to immediately repeal this crappolla, and take us back from the brink of pure socialism.
Welcome to the reality of the big lie called obamacare.
There should be big incentives in all health care policy’s for people to be healthy as in exercise and diet related illness.
Klastri has some esplaining to do hyah ya hear.
And besides that, look at the headline…”Progress slows on uninsured as health law blame game goes on”.
Blame is only on you Klastri and the rest of the liberals. Peanutgallery’s statement above explains why which everyone knows…maybe except the liberals who always cry “Where’s the Repubs fix?”. The blame is on the liberals PERIOD.
The uninsured could have been provided for but to “Throw the Baby Out with the Bath water”..mess up the WHOLE health business was totally insane.
Liberals…crickets…crickets