Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Monday, March 31, 2025 68° Today's Paper


EditorialOur View

Property values soar, depleting lower-cost options

A strong economic recovery in Hawaii has boosted employment, dropping the state’s jobless rate to a 9-year low at 3 percent. It also has raised property values, which, especially in the islands, cuts two ways.

High housing demand and rising property values increase personal wealth and boost prospects for anyone in the sellers’ market, but it also augurs a bigger bill for property taxes for those holding onto the property.

Above all, it further raises Hawaii’s already sky-high housing costs, a particular burden for lower-income residents, many of them already struggling to pay their monthly rent.

Now there’s clear evidence that Oahu’s few “affordable” communities are starting to gentrify. This signals that the window is closing for developing affordable housing, and officials must capitalize on every opportunity to do so.

Specifically, the upward home price trend now is particularly affecting lower-priced properties.

On Oahu, the problem is particularly acute. Last week, Honolulu tax officials reported that the total assessed value of taxable property across the island will rise 5.9 percent in 2017, increasing 5.2 percent for residential owners.

This has been affecting high-end properties for some time, but now the shortage of housing inventory has turned buying interest to the more affordable homes. Waianae Coast will be hit the hardest, with a 12.6 percent rise in assessments.

It’s alarming news for taxpayers there. The city tax collectors multiply the value of a property by a rate set each June by the Honolulu City Council to arrive at the annual tax bill.

Unless there’s a cut in residential rates, Leeward residential property owners will pay taxes that are up by double digits.

But it’s even more alarming for those worried about increasing homelessness. The state is now some 64,000 units short of what it needs to meet housing demand by 2020, according to a 2014 update of figures published by the Hawaii Housing Finance and Development Corp., a state agency that channels public financing to private developers of affordable housing.

In 2014 HHFDC projected that on Oahu, 16,113 dwelling units will be needed to accommodate future housing need. This doubles the size of the housing deficit unmet since 2000.

Oahu’s west side has been growing by leaps and bounds. Kapolei’s university campus, rail terminus and new major shopping center signal that the long-promised “second city” has arrived. Last week more details emerged about a Chinese firm’s plans for its Atlantis resort development at Ko Olina.

Formerly hesitant buyers now see they can live within easy reach of shopping, entertainment, jobs and business — and the Waianae Coast no longer seems so far away.

There are various stakeholder groups who should be taking notice.

City and state officials need to ensure that its special funds to underwrite affordable rental projects are put to optimal use. The city’s newly chartered land management agency should redouble efforts in that direction.

Given that the west coast is home to a large Native Hawaiian population, the Office of Hawaiian Affairs and the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands should be looking for opportunities to acquire land for housing that their beneficiaries can afford. This may involve partnership arrangements or outright purchases.

For example: Rowena Akana, the newly elected chair of the OHA board of trustees, said that she hopes to revive the agency’s past collaborations on “self-help” housing projects, in which future residents invest sweat equity in the building of homes they can purchase. This, and other creative solutions, should be pursued.

Nicole Woo, senior policy analyst at the nonprofit Hawaii Appleseed Center for Law and Economic Justice, said government should look for opportunities to make better use of publicly owned land for public purposes such as housing.

She also cited the potential yield of rental units and other low-cost housing solutions in transit-oriented development (TOD) along the 20-mile rail route, starting in East Kapolei.

That end of the TOD enterprise has yet to materialize, but in the blueprints for towers at the lucrative Ala Moana end of the tracks, developers already seem less than enthused about delivering affordable housing where it’s needed.

For its part, the city administration must see that any exemptions from height and density limits given to developers be offset by significant contributions in public benefits. Affordable rentals for working families and individuals are most critically needed — from the west side to the urban core.

In its April report, “The State of Poverty in Hawai‘i,” Hawaii Appleseed calculated that an hourly wage of $31.61 is needed to afford a market-priced two-bedroom rental. The average hourly wage of a renter here is $14.49.

Clearly, there’s a gap in what the housing market alone will provide. And time is running out for government to build bridges.

15 responses to “Property values soar, depleting lower-cost options”

  1. palani says:

    Waianae Coast will be hit the hardest, with a 12.6 percent rise in assessments.

    Here in Laie, my assessment increased by 20%! Outrageous, considering how little we get for our tax dollars, in terms of efficiency and accountability,

  2. awahana says:

    Here is the report that this article has not provided a link to:

    http://hiappleseed.org/sites/default/files/State%20of%20Poverty%20%5BFINAL%5D.pdf

    It covers a lot of areas you would not realize at first.

    • localguy says:

      Unfortunately union bosses ensure elected bureaucrats keep the tax rates higher than necessary to support lavish union compensation. Undeserved pay raises, bonus payments, excessive pension, on and on. Oh, and to cover their Netflix and HULU subscriptions for union members to watch during work hours.

  3. wiliki says:

    The star Advertiser needs to get its facts straight.

    The rise in real estate prices is not driven by unemployment.

    It’s driven by the humongous shortage in residential housing in Hawaii.

    Now people actually leave Hawaii because of high housing costs.

  4. wave1 says:

    Never be a cut n tax ate as that would mean folks like me who’s value only went up a small amount could end up payin less tax.

  5. Numilalocal says:

    Too many people moving to Hawaii is driving supply and demand. And us locals get priced out of our own home. Sad.

    • wave1 says:

      Where are these peeps working that they can afford a $900k house? I am about to move as hi getting too expensive for what even a good job pays, and I bought the house 17 years ago….

  6. jasurace says:

    My property taxes have more than doubled in the last four years. Two years ago we got hit with a 40% increase in a single year.

  7. saywhatyouthink says:

    Lack of housing is but a symptom of the real problem – too many darn people on one small island.
    Our political leaders have done a poor job in diversifying Hawaii’s economy and expanding economic activity and opportunities to the outer islands. Nearby Kauai and Maui are about the same size as Oahu but have less than 5% of the population. But with no ferry or bridge system to interconnect the islands, growth has been limited to Oahu with all vital goods and services monopolized to the benefit of only a few . In a remotely located island state this makes no sense at all, unless you’re one of those few beneficiaries like the political elite class.
    Keep voting for the long serving corrupt (D) politicians Hawaii, you’re getting exactly what you deserve.

  8. SHOPOHOLIC says:

    But hey!! We get to one day, possibly, maybe, see a “world class” train going back and forth with minimal passengers!!!

    Hahahahahahahahaha!!!!!!

    Hey homeless…go thank Krookwell!!!!

  9. Huivaa says:

    There is no “one” silver bullet that will solve the State’s housing-shortage crises. The state and the counties need to employ a multiple-strategy approach to increase the housing supply. One of the easiest strategies to implement is to shut-down “illegal” vacation rentals in residential zoning. Most studies show there are approximately 5000 residential homes on Oahu that are being used as illegal hotels. Shutting down these illegal businesses would help relieve one third of Oahu’s predicted housing deficit. The City and County of Honolulu needs to take action and simply enforce the current laws on the books! What are they waiting for?

Leave a Reply