A Florida company announced Wednesday it would buy Hawaiian Electric Industries Inc. for $4.3 billion and take on the challenge of moving the state off its near total dependence on imported fossil fuels for power generation.
If the deal wins regulatory approval, Juno Beach, Fla.-based NextEra Energy Inc., the nation’s largest generator of wind and solar power, will become a key player in determining whether Hawaii can break its $5 billion-a-year imported-oil habit. Oil and coal account for 86 percent of Hawaii’s electric power, which leads to monthly bills being nearly triple the average in the U.S.
"In NextEra Energy, Hawaiian Electric is gaining a trusted partner that can help the company accelerate its plans to achieve the clean energy future we all want for Hawaii," said Connie Lau, head of HEI.
NextEra said it hopes to exceed the goals set by HEI in August to increase renewables as a percentage of total energy production to 65 percent, triple the state’s solar power generation and lower customer bills 20 percent by 2030.
NextEra said Hawaiian Electric will keep its name and continue to be based in Honolulu. The company also promised there will be no layoffs for at least two years.
As part of the deal, American Savings Bank, the state’s third-largest financial institution and a subsidiary of HEI, would be spun off. Current HEI shareholders would become owners of the new, independent ASB.
THE DEAL
>> NextEra will pay $4.3 billion to buy HEI. >> HEI shareholders will b e paid $33.50 per share versus Wednesday’s closing price of $28.19. >> NextEra will not lay off workers for two years. >> Hawaiian Electric Co. will maintain the name and continue to be based in Honolulu.
NEXTERA ENERGY INC. Juno Beach, Fla.
>> Employees: 13,900 >> Customers: 4.7 million >> Market cap: $45.6 billion >> CEO James Robo’s 2013 compensation: $10.5 million
HAWAIIAN ELECTRIC INDUSTRIES INC. Honolulu >> Employees: 3,966 >> Customers: 450,000 >> Market cap: $2.9 billion >> CEO Constance Lau’s 2013 compensation: $3.77 million
|
The sale would move control of Hawaii’s leading electric company to the mainland for the first time since it was founded in 1891 by King David Kalakaua.
Reaction was mostly cautious or skeptical among Hawaii renewable energy advocates and political leaders who voiced concern over the shift of HEI’s leadership to a state 5,000 miles away.
Gov. David Ige, who took office Monday, said in a statement: "The state of Hawaii will do its due diligence to ensure the sale will be in the best interest for Hawaii ratepayers. Since Hawaiian Electric Company, Inc. was founded by King David Kalakaua, the state will work to maintain the spirit and values that are consistent with the King’s legacy and honors our culture for future generations."
That sentiment was echoed in a statement by U.S. Sen. Mazie Hirono.
"The decision to combine with NextEra Energy and spin off ASB deserves careful scrutiny on behalf of Hawaii consumers and residents," Hirono said.
Neither politician offered praise for the proposed purchase. Solar industry officials, who have battled HEI over the years for what they saw as foot-dragging on solar expansion, were adamant in their objections to NextEra.
"NextEra’s Florida operations have been historically hostile to rooftop solar and energy efficiency efforts," said Robert Harris, a representative of the Alliance for Solar Choice. "Florida is the ‘Sunshine State,’ and yet only 2,565 of its customers have rooftop solar. This is a utility with over 4.7 million customers."
Florida’s Public Service Commission recently cut its energy efficiency goals and decided to allow a solar rebate program to expire at the end of next year.
NextEra CEO Jim Robo, speaking at a news conference in Honolulu, applauded the commission’s changes as a way to save customers 2 percent on their bills.
"Solar prices have come down so low that those rebates are frankly a little bit out of touch with what is going on in the rest of the country," Robo said.
The 35 percent tax rebate that Hawaii offers on rooftop solar systems and a 30 percent federal tax rebate have given a major boost to the state’s solar industry. More than 11 percent of Hawaiian Electric customers on Oahu have rooftop solar, compared with the U.S. average of 0.5 percent.
Henry Curtis, executive director of Life of the Land, an environmental and community action group, said, "We would be taking a Hawaii company and transferring ownership 5,000 miles away. It’s never good to decrease Hawaii control over such an important asset."
Not all reaction was negative. Blue Planet Foundation Executive Director Jeff Mikulina expressed optimism about the potential the acquisition presents. The nonprofit foundation works in the area of clean energy.
"NextEra brings an exceptional promise of positioning Hawaii as a global clean energy leader," Mikulina said. "They can bring the resources and expertise necessary to help our islands navigate the path to a clean, renewable future."
Several comments concerned the possibility of NextEra pushing for an undersea cable system to connect the Oahu and Maui grids.
For the past two years, NextEra Energy has been working on the project. The project’s future in Hawaii depends on how beneficial it would be for residents, said Robo at the news conference.
"The idea there was to integrate renewable resources from Maui to here in Oahu whether they be wind or solar," Robo said. "The question is it cost effective and that is something that remains to be seen.
State Rep. Cynthia Thielen (R, Kailua-Kaneohe Bay) questioned the wisdom of the cable.
"This means the costly underseas cable is back in play, instead of tapping each island’s renewable resources," she said.
NextEra also could speed Hawaii’s move to import liquefied natural gas to burn to make electricity, said Lau, the HEI chief, in a conference call with investors.
Holders of Hawaiian Electric stock will receive 0.2413 shares in NextEra plus a 50-cent one-time dividend for each share they own. Including an $8 per share estimated value for the ASB spinoff, the deal values Hawaiian Electric at about $33.50 per share, the companies said. That gives a total value of about $3.4 billion.
Without the spinoff, the sale values Honolulu-based Hawaiian Electric at $25.69 a share, or $2.6 billion.
Including debt, the total value of the transaction is about $4.3 billion.
Hawaiian Electric rose 17 percent to $33 after the close in trading in New York. NextEra was unchanged at $104.39.
The deal requires approval from state and federal regulators, in addition to shareholders. It’s expected to be completed within about 12 months.
When asked what her role will be under the new ownership, Lau said, "I frankly haven’t even thought about it."
Star-Advertiser reporter Kathryn Mykleseth and Bloomberg News contributed to this report.
FOLLOWING HEI
A history of Hawaiian Electric Industries Inc.
1881 King David Kalakaua meets Thomas Edison, paving the way for Iolani Palace to become one of the world’s first royal residences to be lit by electricity, in 1886. By 1888, urban Honolulu is lit for the first time.
1891 Hawaiian Electric was incorporated from a royal charter by King David Kalakaua.
1925 American Savings Bank, later a subsidiary of HEI, opens as the American Building & Loan Co.
1937 Waiau Power Plant breaks ground.
1954 The downtown Honolulu Power Plant becomes operational.
1968 Hawaiian Electric’s growth continues with the purchase of Maui Electric Co.
1970 Hawaiian Electric purchases the Hawai‘i Electric Light Co.
1983 Hawaiian Electric is made a subsidiary of HEI.
1988 HEI’s application with the Federal Home Loan Bank for the purchase of American Savings Bank is approved.
1990 American Savings Bank acquires First Nationwide Bank.
1997 American Savings Bank acquires Bank of America’s Hawaii operations and is transformed into Hawaii’s third-largest financial institution.
1998 Hawaiian Electrichelps install the state’s first electric-vehicle, rapid-charging stations, making Honolulu the first city in the nation to do so.
2008 Hawaiian Electric and the state of Hawaii sign the Hawaii Clean Energy Initiative, which sets a goal for the state by 2030 to meet 70 percent of its electricity and ground transportation needs from clean energy sources.
2010 American Savings Bank celebrates its 85th anniversary. Also, the CT-1 Biodiesel power plant helps create a local market for biofuel production in Hawaii.
2013 Hawaiian Electric began receiving power from a new 5-megawatt Kalaeloa Solar Farm in West Oahu. The company also filed a request with the Hawaii Public Utilities Commission to proceed with the development of a 15-megawatt photovoltaic system on undeveloped land at the Kahe Generating Station.
|
2014 DEAL COUNTDOWN
JANUARY
Hawaiian Electric reaches a clean energy milestone with the deactivation of the Honolulu Power Plant.
MAY
Hawaiian Electric President and CEO Richard M. Rosenblum announces his intention to retire within the year.
SEPTEMBER
Hawaiian Electric completes the first phase of a development plan to establish smart grids on Oahu, in Maui County and on Hawaii island by 2018.
NOVEMBER
American Savings Bank is named the top Hawaii Small Business Adminstration lender by issuing 161 loans totaling $6.28 million during the fiscal year.The bank announces plans to build a new corporate campus near downtown Honolulu that will serve as its new Hawaii headquarters, bringing together 600 of its employees from around the island, including its top executives, in a 100,000-square-foot building.
DECEMBER
Hawaiian Electric and Pacific Biodiesel Technologies sign a contract for the Maui-based biofuel company to supply biodiesel processed from waste cooking oil and other local feedstocks, primarily for use at the 110-megawatt Campbell Industrial Park generation facility with the capability for use at other Oahu power plants as needed.
ON WEDNESDAY
Florida-based NextEra Energy agrees to buy Hawaiian Electric Industries for $4.3 billion. Hawaiian Electric Co. will keep its name and continue to be based in Honolulu. HEI also will spin off American Savings Bank as part of the deal. The bank is expected to remain headquartered in Hawaii and led by its current management team.
|